Pen Pal Safety Tips: How to Write to Strangers Safely
By Senne Bels
The first pen pal safety rule: keep personal details private until you trust your pen pal. That includes your full name, home address, phone number and workplace. Keep the first conversations on the app, where you can block and report. Never send money, gift cards or crypto to someone you haven't met. That's the FTC's main rule for romance scams.
Watch out for anyone who declares strong feelings quickly or pushes you to leave the app. Be wary if they always have a reason they can't call. When you switch to paper, use a PO box.
I build penfolk, a pen pal and language exchange app. I won't tell you that any app is perfectly safe, including mine. It isn't. What I can do is explain what goes wrong and what helps.
What to share, and when
Share information in stages. You can move faster with someone you trust, but rushing is how people get hurt.
| Stage | Fine to share | Wait with |
|---|---|---|
| First messages | First name, country or region, hobbies, languages | Full name, city district, workplace, photos of your home |
| After a few weeks | Your city, more photos, a voice note | Phone number, home address, social media with family and friends |
| Once you trust them | A PO box for letters, a video call | Home address, anything about money |
Photos say more than you think. A photo of your street, school uniform or front door may reveal where you live. Some phones add location data to photo files, so check that it's turned off before sharing.
Social media links everything. Your Instagram may reveal your full name, friends, workplace and the café you visit every morning. Don't share it too soon.
Warning signs of a romance or friendship scam
The US Federal Trade Commission describes these signs in What to know about romance scams. They apply to pen pals too:
- They want to leave the app quickly for email, WhatsApp or another chat where reporting is harder.
- They call it true love very early, or the friendship becomes intense faster than feels normal.
- They can't meet or call. The FTC lists familiar excuses: they work on an oil rig, serve in the military or live abroad for an international organisation.
- They ask for money for medical bills, plane tickets, visa fees or a sudden emergency.
- They demand payment through gift cards with the PIN, wire transfers, money transfer apps or cryptocurrency.
- They offer to help you invest, often in crypto.
- They pressure you to act fast.
The FTC's bottom line is simple: never send money or gifts to someone you haven't met in person. If something feels wrong, tell a friend you trust. Someone outside the conversation may spot the problem first.
Try these checks: run a reverse image search on the profile photo to see whether it appears under other names. And search for their story with the word "scam".
Safety on pen pal apps
Most apps offer the same basic tools. Find them before you need them.
- Block anyone who makes you uncomfortable. You don't owe them an explanation.
- Report scams and fake profiles, even after blocking the account. Your report may protect the next person.
- Stay on the app until you trust someone. Reports and moderation only cover messages sent there.
- Limit who can message you if the app supports that setting.
On penfolk, blocking works both ways and doesn't notify the other person. You can report profiles, posts, comments and messages. A first message to someone new can't contain web links, which blocks a common route for scam links. Free accounts can start 10 new conversations each day, slowing mass messaging. You can also restrict messages to friends.
The full list appears on the safety page. penfolk is small and young. It doesn't claim to be risk-free.
Moving from the app to paper letters
Address safety matters most with paper because every letter needs somewhere to go.
- Write online first, for weeks rather than days.
- Use a PO box or mailbox service if you can. It keeps your home address private.
- Keep the return address minimal. A first name and box number are enough.
- Don't send valuables. Flat, inexpensive items are better for everyone.
I wrote more about exchanging addresses and handling postage in snail mail pen pals.
If you decide to meet
Some pen pals meet in person, especially when one of them travels. If you do:
- Video call first to check that they are who they claim to be.
- Meet in a busy public place during daylight.
- Tell a friend where you'll be and when you'll check in.
- Arrange your own transport and accommodation.
- Leave if anything feels wrong. You can always say no.
If something already went wrong
- Stop replying. Block the person and report the profile to the app.
- If you sent money, contact your bank, gift card company or transfer service straight away and ask about a refund. Earlier is better.
- Report the scam. In the US, use ReportFraud.ftc.gov. Elsewhere, contact your national fraud reporting service or the police.
- Keep screenshots of the messages and profile.
Being scammed doesn't mean you were stupid. The people behind these scams do it every day.
For broader advice on choosing someone to write to, see how to find a pen pal.
FAQ
How do I find a pen pal safely?
Use an app or site with blocking and reporting. Write a specific profile and keep your first conversations on the app. Share personal details in stages as trust develops.
What is the safest pen pal website?
No pen pal site is risk-free. Look for blocking, reporting, clear rules and a way to restrict who can message you. Your choices about sharing personal details matter more than the site you choose.
Should I give my pen pal my address?
Only after you trust them. Ideally, give them a PO box instead of your home address. Never share an address with someone who pressures you for it early.
How can I tell if a pen pal is a scammer?
Warning signs include quick declarations of love, pressure to leave the app, repeated excuses for avoiding calls or meetings, and any request for money, gift cards or crypto. A reverse image search on the profile photo may also help.
What should I do if a pen pal asks for money?
Don't send it. Stop replying, then block and report the person. If you've already paid, contact your bank or payment service immediately. In the US, report the scam at ReportFraud.ftc.gov.